Casey Key Homes for Sale

Real Estate in Casey Key, Florida

View every homes for sale in Casey Key below. Sign up to create an account to receive new property email alerts, price change alerts, track your favorite properties & more!

If you like a homes in Casey Key you can add it to your favorites, request more information or set up a showing. 

Jump To: Casey Key Listings | Contact Us | Create An Account

Homes For Sale in Casey Key

[si-all-subdivision-Casey Key]

View all Casey Key Homes for Sale July 19, 2024
Avg. DOM
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
Med. List Price
19 Properties
Page 1 of 2

Casey Key, Florida

Over the pristine waters of the Gulf of Mexico lies Casey Key, a hidden gem waiting to be explored. Known for its luxurious oceanfront estates and unspoiled beaches, this barrier island offers a serene retreat for travelers seeking a tranquil escape. Despite its beauty, visitors should be cautious of the strong currents and potentially hazardous wildlife in the area. Dive into the tranquility and charm of Casey Key, Florida, and discover why this destination is a must-visit for those who appreciate nature's untouched beauty.

Key Takeaways:

  • Luxurious Beach Destination: Casey Key in Florida is known for its exclusive and luxurious beachfront properties.
  • Private and Secluded: The island offers a private and secluded getaway, perfect for those seeking tranquility and relaxation.
  • Breathtaking Views: Visitors to Casey Key can enjoy stunning views of the Gulf of Mexico and beautiful sunsets from pristine beaches.
  • Exclusive Real Estate: The area is home to upscale homes and estates, making it a sought-after location for affluent buyers.
  • Nearby Attractions: While secluded, Casey Key is in close proximity to popular attractions such as Sarasota and Venice, offering a perfect blend of relaxation and entertainment.



For those seeking a peaceful escape with stunning natural beauty, Casey Key in Florida is the perfect destination. Located on the southwest coast of Florida, Casey Key is a barrier island nestled between Sarasota and Venice. Enjoying the view of the Gulf of Mexico to the west and the Intracoastal Waterway to the east, Casey Key offers a unique blend of tranquility and breathtaking vistas.


An ideal subtropical climate blesses Casey Key, making it a year-round paradise for visitors. With warm temperatures and plenty of sunshine, this barrier island experiences mild winters and warm summers, perfect for beach activities and outdoor adventures. The sea breezes help to mitigate the heat, creating a comfortable environment for residents and tourists alike.

To truly appreciate the beauty of Casey Key, visit during the winter months when the temperatures are cooler, and the crowds are fewer. This allows for a more intimate experience with the island's natural surroundings and a chance to unwind in a serene environment.

1. Exclusive barrier island with luxury waterfront properties. 2. Known for its white sandy beaches and crystal-clear waters. 3. Peaceful and tranquil atmosphere perfect for relaxation. 4. Limited public access, ensuring privacy and seclusion. 5. Popular destination for fishing, boating, and water sports. 6. Home to upscale dining and shopping experiences.


Some say that the history of Casey Key, Florida, is as rich and diverse as the beautiful landscapes that can be found on this narrow barrier island. From the indigenous peoples who first inhabited the area to the early settlers who established roots here, Casey Key has seen significant changes over the centuries.

Indigenous Peoples

History tells us that the Calusa tribe were the original inhabitants of this region. These skilled fishermen and hunters thrived in the abundance of natural resources that the Gulf Coast had to offer. Their presence on the island dates back thousands of years, leaving behind traces of their civilization in the form of shell mounds and artifacts.

Early Settlement

The early 1800s saw the arrival of European settlers to Casey Key, looking to take advantage of the fertile land and strategic location for trade. The pioneers who made this island their home faced challenges but also found solace in the tranquil beauty that surrounded them. The development of the island began with small communities forming along the coast, slowly but steadily expanding over time.

The settlers on Casey Key quickly discovered the benefits of the lush landscape, with ample opportunities for farming and fishing. The idyllic setting of the island soon attracted more people seeking a peaceful way of life away from the bustling mainland.

Development and Growth

Plus, as the years went by, Casey Key underwent further development and growth, transforming from a quiet retreat into a desirable destination for vacationers and residents alike. The construction of bridges connecting the island to the mainland made it more accessible, leading to an increase in visitors and new residents.

Over time, luxurious waterfront estates and upscale amenities became synonymous with Casey Key, drawing in influential figures and celebrities looking for a private oasis along the Gulf Coast. The charming blend of natural beauty and modern comforts continues to attract those seeking a slice of paradise in this exclusive enclave.

On Development and Growth

On top of the residential expansion, commercial establishments such as restaurants, shops, and recreational facilities sprang up to cater to the growing population and tourism industry on Casey Key. This influx of businesses added to the island's appeal as a well-rounded destination for both leisure and living.


Despite its rapid growth and popularity, Casey Key has managed to retain much of its natural charm and unspoiled beauty, making it a cherished gem along the Florida coastline. The preservation efforts and conservation initiatives in place ensure that this idyllic island continues to enchant visitors with its pristine beaches and tranquil atmosphere.



Not only is Casey Key known for its luxurious homes and exclusive lifestyle, but it also boasts some of the most beautiful beaches in Florida. The soft, white sand and clear blue waters make it the perfect spot for sunbathing, swimming, and beachcombing. Visitors can enjoy a leisurely stroll along the shore or simply relax under the shade of an umbrella while listening to the soothing sound of the waves.

Water Sports

For those looking for a bit more adventure, Casey Key offers a variety of water sports opportunities. From jet skiing and parasailing to paddleboarding and kayaking, there's something for everyone to enjoy. The calm waters of the Gulf provide the ideal conditions for these activities, allowing visitors to experience the thrill of speeding across the waves or peacefully exploring the coastline.

Sports: If you're feeling more daring, you can even try your hand at windsurfing or kiteboarding, taking advantage of the area's breezy conditions.

Nature Reserves

Any nature enthusiast will appreciate the serene beauty of the nature reserves on Casey Key. Home to a variety of native plants and wildlife, these protected areas offer a glimpse into Florida's natural habitats. Visitors can hike along scenic trails, birdwatch, or simply take in the peaceful surroundings while immersing themselves in the local ecosystem.

The Oscar Scherer State Park is a must-visit for nature lovers, offering opportunities for camping, picnicking, and wildlife viewing in a pristine natural setting.


Unlike other popular tourist destinations, Casey Key offers a more laid-back and tranquil experience for visitors looking to engage in a variety of activities. From fishing to boating, and hiking to biking, there is something for everyone to enjoy on this serene barrier island.


The fishing opportunities on Casey Key are abundant, with the chance to catch a variety of species in the surrounding waters. Whether you prefer to fish from the shore, a pier, or a chartered boat, you are sure to have a memorable experience. The crystal-clear waters provide an ideal setting for anglers of all skill levels to reel in their catch of the day.


With boating being a popular pastime on Casey Key, visitors can explore the beautiful coastline and surrounding areas from the water. Whether you bring your own boat or rent one locally, the calm waters of the Gulf of Mexico offer a serene setting for a day of cruising or fishing. The scenic views and abundant marine life make boating an unforgettable experience for all who venture out.

For those looking to fully immerse themselves in the boating experience, guided tours and excursions are available, providing a more in-depth look at the rich ecosystem and history of the area. Whether you're interested in dolphin watching, sunset cruises, or deep-sea fishing, there are plenty of options to satisfy your seafaring desires.

Hiking and Biking

For hiking and biking enthusiasts, Casey Key offers a picturesque backdrop to explore on foot or two wheels. The island's quiet roads and scenic pathways provide the perfect opportunity to take in the lush tropical landscapes and pristine beaches. Whether you're looking for a leisurely stroll or a challenging bike ride, the natural beauty of Casey Key will not disappoint.

For a more rugged adventure, visitors can explore biking trails that wind through the mangroves and coastal hammocks, offering a unique perspective of the island's diverse flora and fauna. Whether you're an experienced hiker or a casual biker, Casey Key's natural wonders are sure to leave a lasting impression on all who venture into its unspoiled wilderness.


Luxury Resorts

One of the best ways to experience the luxurious side of Casey Key is by staying at one of the upscale resorts that line the pristine beaches. These resorts offer top-notch amenities, breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico, and world-class service that will make your stay truly unforgettable. Whether you prefer lounging by the pool or enjoying water sports, these luxury resorts have everything you need for a relaxing and indulgent vacation.

Vacation Rentals


Another popular accommodation option on Casey Key is vacation rentals. These range from cozy beachfront cottages to spacious villas with private pools. Staying in a vacation rental gives you the flexibility to create your own schedule and truly feel at home while on vacation. Many vacation rentals also come with fully equipped kitchens, allowing you to cook your own meals and enjoy them al fresco on your private patio.

Camping Options



Dining and Nightlife

Your culinary journey on Casey Key will be a delightful experience with a plethora of dining options ranging from fresh seafood to fine dining establishments.

Seafood Restaurants

An array of seafood restaurants line the shores of Casey Key, offering the freshest catch of the day. These establishments serve up delectable dishes such as grilled grouper, seared scallops, and key lime pie, all while providing stunning views of the Gulf of Mexico. Indulge in the local flavors and immerse yourself in a true seaside dining experience.

Local Bars and Pubs

For a more laid-back evening, head to one of the cozy local bars or lively pubs on Casey Key. These establishments offer a relaxed atmosphere where you can enjoy a refreshing cocktail or a cold beer after a day of exploring the area. Experience the warm hospitality of the locals and unwind in a casual setting.

Whether you prefer a waterfront bar with live music or a quaint pub with a selection of craft beers, Casey Key has something for every taste. Make sure to check out the local entertainment schedule for a night filled with live music and good company.

Fine Dining Experiences

The fine dining scene on Casey Key is nothing short of spectacular, with elegant restaurants that offer a refined culinary experience. Indulge in gourmet dishes prepared with locally sourced ingredients and paired with exquisite wines. The attentive service and upscale ambiance make these establishments perfect for a special evening out.

Pubs on Casey Key aren't just places to grab a pint; they also offer a high-end dining experience with a casual twist. Enjoy elevated pub fare such as truffle fries, short rib sliders, and artisanal cheese boards in a relaxed setting with a touch of sophistication.

Dining on Casey Key is a feast for the senses, with a variety of restaurants and bars that cater to every palate. Whether you're in the mood for fresh seafood, a casual night out, or a lavish dining experience, Casey Key has something for everyone.


From above, Casey Key in Florida stands out as a hidden gem for travelers seeking a peaceful and luxurious beach getaway. Its pristine beaches, upscale properties, and secluded atmosphere make it a truly picturesque destination. Whether you're looking to relax on the sand, explore the local wildlife, or simply unwind in a serene environment, Casey Key offers a unique and unforgettable experience.

With its exclusive atmosphere and stunning natural beauty, Casey Key is sure to captivate visitors looking for a tranquil escape. This article has highlighted the key attractions and features of this charming destination, inspiring travelers to consider adding Casey Key to their list of must-visit locations. Whether you prefer laid-back beach days or adventurous water activities, Casey Key, Florida, promises a one-of-a-kind vacation experience that will leave you rejuvenated and in awe of its beauty.


Q: What is Casey Key?

A: Casey Key is a barrier island located off the coast of Sarasota, Florida, known for its luxurious homes, pristine beaches, and serene atmosphere.

Q: How do I get to Casey Key, Florida?

A: Casey Key is easily accessible by car via Interstate 75, followed by Route 681 or Route 41. The closest airport is Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport, just a short drive away.

Q: What are some popular activities to do on Casey Key?

A: Popular activities on Casey Key include relaxing on the beach, swimming in the clear Gulf waters, shelling, fishing, and birdwatching. Its tranquil environment also makes it perfect for romantic getaways or peaceful retreats.

Q: Are there places to stay on Casey Key?

A: While Casey Key is primarily known for its private residences, there are a few boutique hotels, inns, and vacation rentals available for visitors looking to stay on the island.

Q: What is the best time of year to visit Casey Key?

A: The best time to visit Casey Key is during the winter months when the weather is mild and pleasant. This is also the peak season for tourists, so be sure to book accommodations in advance.